Social Shares Aren’t Pulling Images

When I share to Facebook (possibly other social sites, too, but I don’t use those share options often), it’s not pulling any images. I have images set in the “social” tab, but when I share to Facebook (either manually or via my sharing plugin) it pulls nothing. Not the wrong image, just nothing. I always have to manually share my posts to Facebook and then manually upload the image, but that means when readers are trying to share the posts, they’re being shared without images.

I’m not sure what’s broken. I do have Shareaholic also installed, and don’t know if maybe I need to disable open graph in that so they won’t conflict?

e.g. this is a recent post: https://titus2homemaker.com/you-are-a-child-of-god-review/